MATLAB Answers


How to compare matrices with different dimensions?

Asked by phdcomputer Eng on 22 Jun 2019
Latest activity Commented on by Guillaume
on 24 Jun 2019
I wrote a code for classification by using 5 classifiers and at the end I used voting this code is for initia defining of train and test data:
clear all
close all
load liver.mat;
I put the resault of each classifier in out 1-5 and then aggregate them in output and compared output with test labels :
out1 = majorityvote(tt(1,:));
out2 = majorityvote(tt(2,:));
out3 = majorityvote(tt(3,:));
out4 = majorityvote(tt(4,:) );
out5 = majorityvote(tt(5,:) );
for i=1:test_count
if(output(i)==1 && ytest(i)==1)
if(output(i)==0 && ytest(i)==0)
if(output(i)==0 && ytest(i)==1)
if(output(i)==1 && ytest(i)==0)
this codes doesn't have any problems with other datasets in this part but for the liver data (attached) It shows this error:
Index exceeds matrix dimensions.
Error in pimaclassify_new (line 174)
if(output(i)==1 && ytest(i)==1)
Maybe because the number of test_count for specified number of rows of data were obtained 5 so comparing them with test labels was true but for liver data which have different number of rows , this comparing shows error.
Should I change the sizes of outputs of classifiers or the size of test data or test_count?
I'll be grateful to have your opinions about fixing the error.


I strongly suspect that
output(1) = majorityvote(tt(1,:));
would result in an error. Since majorityvote, whatever that is, is indexed by a row vector, presumably with more than 1 element (otherwise why the : ?), it is very likely to return more than one element.
Now, depending on the shape of majorityvector and tt, the concatenation of [out1, out2, ...] is going to return a 2D matrix (if majorityvector is a column vector or a matrix), or a row vector (if majorityvector is a row vector).
Assuming the former, then this would problably work:
output = zeros(size(tt, 1), 5);
output(:, 1) = majorityvote(tt(1, :));
output(:, 2) = ...
which is simply the one liner
output = majorityvote(tt); %assuming tt has 5 columns, otherwise tt(1:5, :)
You bring up a good point about the size of the output of majorityvote, I should not have assumed it was a single element. With that said though, why would the result be a single column vector, when the input is a single row vector. It would make sense with the original concatenation of output, but it seems like a confusing way to write the function. Also, do we know that majorityvote(tt) will automatically consider the rows individually, or will it simple take the entire array as a single large input?
If majorityvote is a vector, since tt(row, :) is a vector (column or row doesn't matter), then majorityvote(tt(row, :)) will be the same shape as majorityvote. A(B) is the shape of A when both A and B are vectors
If majorityvote is not a vector, then majorityvote(tt(row, :)) will be the same shape as tt(row, :) hence a column vector. A(B) is the shape of B when either A or B is not a vector.
An annoying or useful inconsistency depending on your point of view.
A corollary of the above is that output = majorityvote(tt) will be the same size as tt, with output(r, c) equal to majorityvote(tt(r, c))

Sign in to comment.

0 Answers