Efficient way to calculate backwards average

25 views (last 30 days)
Dear all,
I'm looking for an efficient way to calculate a backwards moving average, i.e., giving a vector A I want to calculate a vector A2 for which the element i is equal to mean(A(i:end)).
For the moment I am doing it this way:
A=rand(1,1000);
n=length(A);
A2=zeros(1,n)
for i=1:n
A2(i)=mean(A(i:end));
end
Is there any better way?
Thanks
Lorenzo

Accepted Answer

John D'Errico
John D'Errico on 29 Sep 2014
Edited: John D'Errico on 29 Sep 2014
First of all, what you SAY you are doing makes no sense. A is a 1000x1000 matrix, but A2 only a vector. And you have two i for loops, with only one end. And regardless of what size A is, n=size(A) will produce a vector. So 1:n will yield a problem in the for loop.
The code you show will fail in so many ways I won't bother to count. You should provide working code so someone can know what it is you really want!
Assuming that you really wanted to write this where A is a row vector...
Think about what cumsum does. Then, suppose you flipped the data before calling cumsum.
n = length(A);
A2 = fliplr(cumsum(fliplr(A))./(1:n)));
Of course, this is really not a true moving average, since that would involve a moving window of fixed length. But it is what you asked for.
  4 Comments
John D'Errico
John D'Errico on 1 Oct 2014
That will work fine, although a minor optimization would be to use bsxfun to do the divide instead of replicating the vector using repmat.
A2=flipud(bsxfun(@rdivide,cumsum(flipud(A)),(1:rows)'));

Sign in to comment.

More Answers (4)

José-Luis
José-Luis on 29 Sep 2014
numRows = 100;
numCols = 100;
data = rand(numRows,numCols);
result = flipud(bsxfun(@rdivide,cumsum(flipud(data)),(1:numRows)));
  1 Comment
Lorenzo
Lorenzo on 30 Sep 2014
Thanks José. I'm getting something weird at the end of the signal though… In case of a vector it should be:
result(end)=data(end)
but I'm not getting this with your method…

Sign in to comment.


Chad Greene
Chad Greene on 29 Sep 2014
This is a very fast moving average calculator. It centers data, so if you use an N-point moving average, after calculating the moving averaged, you could shift by N/2 to get the "backwards" moving average.
  1 Comment
Image Analyst
Image Analyst on 29 Sep 2014
He doesn't want a moving average. His window is not constant length, but gets shorter as the index approaches the end of the array.

Sign in to comment.


SK
SK on 29 Sep 2014
Edited: SK on 29 Sep 2014
s = sum(A);
n = length(A);
A2 = (s - cumsum(A))/n;
is a little more elegant and I would think faster. But you have to add s/N to the beginning of A2 and remove the 0 at the end of A2.
The last operation (removing the zero) is misleadingly innocent:
A2(end) = [];
But you may soon get to know the consequences of it.
  1 Comment
Lorenzo
Lorenzo on 30 Sep 2014
Thanks SK. This doesn't seem to do what I need though… not sure what it is supposed to do…

Sign in to comment.


Lorenzo
Lorenzo on 30 Sep 2014
Edited: Lorenzo on 30 Sep 2014
Thanks everybody for the answers.
With a vector of 50k elements I get the following run time:
my method: 10.17 s
John's method: 0.006 s
  1 Comment
Stephen23
Stephen23 on 30 Sep 2014
Unless you are actually answering your own question, write a comment to your original question or one of the answers. There is no guarantee that the answers remain in any particular order...

Sign in to comment.

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!