How to speed up find and unique

3 views (last 30 days)
Chaoyang Jiang
Chaoyang Jiang on 26 Apr 2018
Commented: Chaoyang Jiang on 26 Apr 2018
I did the profiling where unique and find take the most of time.
I use find as I want to know the row and column index of the 1 elements in a. For unique, I only need the index.
a=randi([0 1], 20000,8736);
temp=randi(8737, 4000,1000);
for i=1000
[aa0,aa00]=find(a(:,temp(:,i))==1);
[~,aa001,~]=unique(aa00);
end
May I know how to speed up? Thank you.
  2 Comments
Walter Roberson
Walter Roberson on 26 Apr 2018
I think your aa001 should be equivalent to
aa001 = find(diff([0; aa0]));
which is an abbreviation for
aa001 = [1; find(diff(aa0) ~= 0)];
which is looking for the places where aa0 changes.
Potentially faster would be
aa001 = [1; find(aa0(1:end-1) ~= aa0(2:end))];
but with the two intermediate arrays you would really have to do a timing test to be sure which variation was faster.
Chaoyang Jiang
Chaoyang Jiang on 26 Apr 2018
Thank you for your answer. The output of aa001 = find(diff([0; aa0])) is the unique value, while in my code, [~,aa001,~]=unique(aa00) the output is the unqiue value index. They are not same.

Sign in to comment.

Answers (0)

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!