int function is not working properly in matlab

4 views (last 30 days)
Anal
Anal on 13 May 2024
Commented: Anal on 16 May 2024
Following is my script to integrate a function in matlab2023a. Here If I put n_S approximately 50 and i=50, the code does work. But for large value as n_S=100 and i=100 it does not work. Could you help me to what could be the reaso n behind that.
clc
clear
del_0_S=4.0493532;
n_S=100;
n_star_S=vpa(n_S-del_0_S);
Energy_S=vpa(-1/(2*n_star_S^2));
l_s=0; l_d=2; s=1/100; % l values of S, P, D, and F states
syms r
W_i=((whittakerW(n_star_S, l_s+0.5,(2.*(r))./(n_star_S))));
Gii=(W_i./((sqrt(n_star_S.^2.*gamma(n_star_S+l_s+1).*gamma(n_star_S-l_s)))));
del_0_D3=2.47545;
%
n_D3=5:115;
for i=100
n_star_D3(i)=double(n_D3(i)-del_0_D3);% Effective n
Energy_D3(i)=double((-1/(2*n_star_D3(i)^2)));
W_f_D3(i)=(whittakerW(n_star_D3(i), l_d+0.5,(2.*(r))./(n_star_D3(i))));
Gff_D3(i)=(W_f_D3(i)./((sqrt(n_star_D3(i).^2.*gamma(n_star_D3(i)+l_d+1).*gamma(n_star_D3(i)-l_d)))));
fun_S_D3(i)=(((r).^2).*Gii.*Gff_D3(i));
r_min_S_D3(i)=double((s*n_S*n_D3(i)/((n_D3(i)+n_S))));
Matrix_element_S_D3(i)=double((int(fun_S_D3(i),r_min_S_D3(i),25000)));
end

Answers (2)

Torsten
Torsten on 13 May 2024
Moved: Torsten on 13 May 2024
Evaluate
gamma(n_star_D3(i)+l_d+1)
gamma(n_star_D3(i)-l_d)
and you will see the reason.
Consequently, Gff_D3(i) becomes 0.

Walter Roberson
Walter Roberson on 14 May 2024
Moved: Walter Roberson on 14 May 2024
Your Gii is pretty small.
Your Gff_D3 is pretty small.
Multiply the two together and you get a value small enough that it is smaller than realmin
Your integral comes out as 0.
Q = @(v) sym(v);
del_0_S = Q(40493532) / Q(10)^7;
n_S = Q(100);
n_star_S = n_S-del_0_S;
Energy_S = -1/(2*n_star_S^2);
l_s = Q(0); l_d = Q(2); s = Q(1/100); % l values of S, P, D, and F states
syms r
W_i=((whittakerW(n_star_S, l_s+0.5,(2.*(r))./(n_star_S))));
Gii=(W_i./((sqrt(n_star_S.^2.*gamma(n_star_S+l_s+1).*gamma(n_star_S-l_s)))));
del_0_D3 = Q(247545) / Q(10)^5;
%
n_D3=5:115;
for i=100
n_star_D3(i) = n_D3(i)-del_0_D3;% Effective n
Energy_D3(i) = (-1/(2*n_star_D3(i)^2));
W_f_D3(i) = (whittakerW(n_star_D3(i), l_d+0.5,(2.*(r))./(n_star_D3(i))));
Gff_D3(i) = (W_f_D3(i)./((sqrt(n_star_D3(i).^2.*gamma(n_star_D3(i)+l_d+1).*gamma(n_star_D3(i)-l_d)))));
fun_S_D3(i) = (((r).^2).*Gii.*Gff_D3(i));
r_min_S_D3(i) = (s*n_S*n_D3(i)/((n_D3(i)+n_S)));
%{
temp = int(fun_S_D3(i),r_min_S_D3(i),25000);
Matrix_element_S_D3(i) = double(temp);
%}
vpa(Gii, 10)
vpa(Gff_D3(i), 10)
vpa(fun_S_D3(i), 10)
end
ans = 
ans = 
ans = 
%Matrix_element_S_D3(i)
  2 Comments
Anal
Anal on 14 May 2024
Edited: Anal on 14 May 2024
This is the plot of Gii with r. Even though the denomenator of Gii is very small. It compensates with the numarator which is W_i.
Actually I am getting the following error when I choose n_S=100 an i=100. For smaller values of both quantities, the code works.
"Unable to convert expression containing remaining symbolic function calls into double array.
Argument must be expression that evaluates to number.
Error in sym/double (line 729)
Xstr = mupadmex('symobj::double', S.s, 0);"
Is there any other process to solve this problem?
Anal
Anal on 16 May 2024
I think that it is better to solve numerically by writting the whole code and not just by calling matlab function.

Sign in to comment.

Products


Release

R2023a

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!