How do I integrate this expression?
Show older comments
I have an expression for force here:
f =1.3e7*((500*y).*(0.46775*cos(60*t+0.2094395101999999e6*x)+0.37843*cos(2*(60*t+0.2094395101999999e6*x))+0.25228*cos(3*(60*t+0.2094395101999999e6*x))+0.1169*cos(4*(60*t+0.2094395101999999e6*x)))/1);
I need to integrate this expression w.r.t y and x (double integral), keeping t fixed.
Any idea how I could do this?
Answers (1)
Walter Roberson
on 15 Nov 2012
That expression is numeric GIGO (Garbage In, Garbage Out). You have 1.3e7 which is only two decimal places of precision, but you also have 0.2094395101999999e6 which is 16 decimal places ending in 999999 that looks like blindly copied floating point numbers that should have been rounded.
But anyhow. Letting the limits be y0 and y1, and x0 and x1, the integral is
(5021948750/3848451) * (y0+y1) * ((140325/25228) * sin(60*t + (10262536/49) * x0) + (113529/50456) * sin(120*t + (20525072/49) * x0) + sin(180*t + (30787608/49) * x0) + (2505/7208) * sin(240*t + (41050144/49) * x0) - (140325/25228) * sin(60*t + (10262536/49) * x1) - (113529/50456) * sin(120*t + (20525072/49) * x1) - sin(180*t + (30787608/49) * x1) - (2505/7208) * sin(240*t + (41050144/49) * x1)) * (y0-y1)
Choose the number of digits of precision wisely when you convert to floating point.
4 Comments
Yagnaseni Roy
on 15 Nov 2012
Walter Roberson
on 15 Nov 2012
What integration bounds are you testing with?
When I test over y=0..3, x=1..7, and then plot over t=0..Pi/15, the difference I get between the above expression (with fractions) and the integral of the floating point version, is fairly obviously due to numeric round off differences caused by propagation of the low number of digits of precision. The graph of the integral is completely periodic either way.
If you were trying to integrate to infinity you would have problems with the integral, as limit(sin(x), x->infinity) is undefined.
Yagnaseni Roy
on 16 Nov 2012
Walter Roberson
on 16 Nov 2012
I used Maple. The coefficients are the same as you used, just expressed as rational numbers.
Categories
Find more on Numerical Integration and Differentiation in Help Center and File Exchange
Community Treasure Hunt
Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!
Start Hunting!