3 views (last 30 days)

Show older comments

I have a non-linear system of four inequalities (constraints) that I wish to solve for the two variables S and G, as follows:

I can solve this using WolframAlpha as shown here, but am curious how to solve this problem using MATLAB? Either a symbolic solution (like Wolfram provides) or a set of possible integer solutions (or something alike).

John D'Errico
on 21 Aug 2021

Start with, what can we do in symbolic form?

syms S G real

Eq(1) = G > 21;

Eq(2) = S >= 15;

Eq(3) = S <= 18;

Eq(4) = 61 <= 2*S + G;

Eq(5) = 2*S + G <= 63;

Eq(6) = atand(S/G) >= 30;

Eq(7) = atand(S/G) <= 45;

solve(Eq,S,G,'returnconditions',true)

There are infinitely many real solutions. So solve cannot handle the problem.

Those inequalities are all just linear though, linear in S and G. Even the case of the atan is linear, sicne over a limited region, the tangent function is monotonic. So we know that if

atand(S/G) <= 45

then by taking the tangent of both sides, we do not change the sign of the inequality. That tells us:

S/G <= 1

or

S <= G

Likewise, we can infer that

S/G >= sqrt(3/3)

So we have

S >= sqrt(3)/3*G

There is a nice utility called plotregion, that lives on the file exchange for free download. If we represent this linear sytem of inequalities by the matrix A and vector b, where A*x >= b, we might do:

LB = [15 21]; % lower bounds on S and G respectively

UB = [18 inf]; % upper bounds on S and G

A = [2 1;-2 -1;-1 1;1 -sqrt(3)/3]; % linear inequalities

b = [61;-63;0;0];

plotregion(A,b,LB,UB)

xlabel 'S'

ylabel 'G'

grid on

That region in the (S,G) plane is where your solutions live. There are infinintely many pairs of real solutions. It looks like Alpha was willing to generate some of them.

If you wish to show the integer solutions, a simple graphical way to do so is to overlay an integer lattice on top of that domain.

[s,g] = meshgrid(16:18,25:30);

hold on

plot(s,g,'ro')

Where you should see the six pairs of integer solutions that live in the solution locus. Five of them lie on the boundary, one is interior.

Alan Stevens
on 21 Aug 2021

First plot some lines that bound the inequalities

% G>21

% 15<=S<=18

% 61<=2S+G<=63

% 30<=atan(S/G)<=45 -> sqrt(3)/3 <= S/G <= 1 -> G<=sqrt(3)S and G>=S

% Define functions

G1 = @(S) 61 - 2*S; % G >= G1

G2 = @(S) 63 - 2*S; % G <= G2

G3 = @(S) sqrt(3)*S; % G <= G3

S = [15 18];

plot(S,G1(S),S,G2(S),S,G3(S)),grid

s1 = 61/(2+sqrt(3)); s2 = 63/(2+sqrt(3));

g1 = G1(s1); g2 = G2(s2);

patch([s1, 18, 18, s2], [g1, 25, 27, g2],'y')

xlabel('S'), ylabel('G')

% then find the intersection points.

% The solutions are in the yellow patch area.

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!