Problem 42787. How many ways to write
Solution Stats
Problem Comments

5 Comments
In the test case, not enough input variables.
Unless I am misunderstanding the question, the correct result for x=7 and n=3 is y_correct=21, not 66.
The author's problem seems to be wrong. I am pretty sure that there are 105 possible triplets that add to 7 within the required range (if order matters). See explanation bellow:
3 positive numbers that add to 7: nchoosek(6,2) (apply the stars and bars theorem on a set with 7 ones)
0 and 2 positive numbers that add to 7: nchoosek(6,1) (pick 0 and apply the stars and bars theorem) times 3 since 0 can be at 3 positions
1 and 2 positive numbers that add to 8: nchoosek(7,1) (pick 1 and apply the stars and bars theorem) times 3 since 1 can be at 3 positions
2 and 2 positive numbers that add to 9: nchoosek(8,1) (pick 2 and apply the stars and bars theorem) times 3 since 2 can be at 3 positions
And finally we have the unique triplets:
[0, 0, m1], [0,1,m2], [0,2,m3], [1,1,m4], [1,2,m5], [2,2,m6] in which each mi has only one possible value. Where a number repeats there are 3 possibilities and where none repeat 6.
Adding every case results in 105 possible triplets, not 66.
I've also discovered that for some reason nchoosek(12,2)=66 (which alledgedly would be the way to obtain 7 summing 3 numbers), and that nchoosek(79,3)=79079 (which alledgedly would be the way to obtain 40 summing 4 numbers, but I really doubt that's true: following the same reasoning described above we obtain a different number).
PS: It seems that only the first case of the test suite is correct. The 3 pairs for obtaining 1 are [0,1],[1,2] and [2,3].
Silly me, forgot we could just generate them all at a computer, and as William said it, there are 21 unique triples that add to 7 within the required range (if order does not matter), namely:
x =
2 2 11
2 1 10
2 0 9
2 1 8
2 2 7
2 3 6
2 4 5
1 1 9
1 0 8
1 1 7
1 2 6
1 3 5
1 4 4
0 0 7
0 1 6
0 2 5
0 3 4
1 1 5
1 2 4
1 3 3
2 2 3
Apart from things other have pointed, 1st test case violates the problem statement.
Solution Comments
Show commentsProblem Recent Solvers5
Suggested Problems

230 Solvers

493 Solvers

Back to basics 24  Symbolic variables
142 Solvers

51 Solvers

How many monitors are connected ?
151 Solvers
More from this Author5
Problem Tags
Community Treasure Hunt
Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!
Start Hunting!