Problem 1943. Signed Magnitude

Created by Greg

Solve Later

For a given input vector, return the value that is furthest from zero.

For example, if

x = [1 2 -12]

return -12.

Solve

Solution Stats

177 Solutions
94 Solvers

Last Solution submitted on Aug 25, 2019

Last 200 Solutions

Problem Comments

1 Comment

1 Comment

Jon on 9 Apr 2014

Really needs a better test suite that doesn't have the correct answer in the same position.

Solution Comments

Solution 1242349

5 Comments

5 Comments

Show 2 older comments

yurenchu on 30 Jul 2017

Why does this not work?

Peng Liu on 30 Jul 2017

Because x + 0i and complex(x) are fundamentally different in MATLAB. In MATLAB, x+0i is always real variable given that x is real, i.e., it only requires 8 bytes to store x+0i (for real double x), whereas complex(x) is a complex variable which consumes 16 bytes, with 8 bytes storing the real part (x) and 8 bytes storing the imaginary part (which is 0 in this case). You may verify this by the following snippet: [a,b,c] = deal(1,1+0i,complex(1)); whos a b c

yurenchu on 31 Jul 2017

Thanks for your neat and detailed explanation, Peng Liu. I had expected/assumed that "x+0i" would work the same as "complex(x)", because in the description on the MATLAB documentation page of the complex() function, it says "if x is real, then z is x + 0i", without directly mentioning anything about the fundamental difference in how the variable is stored.

Binbin Qi on 1 Aug 2017

@yurenchu, in the bottom of the document of MATLAB , there is a Tip, said "If b contains only zeros, then z is complex and the value of all its imaginary components is 0. In contrast, the addition a + 0i returns a strictly real result."

yurenchu on 1 Aug 2017

Thanks, Binbin Qi. It seems that I had somehow missed/overlooked that part when I read that page earlier.

Problem Recent Solvers94

Problem Tags

matlab